Cookie Consent by Free Privacy Policy Generator
Panato Law Firm — Verona logo

Search

Enter a keyword to start searching

Content developed with the assistance of AI tools and reviewed by the author.

AGCM Fines Italy: Dual Liability After the Lidl Ruling - Panato Law Firm — Verona

How a single misleading label or dark-pattern website can now attract two overlapping sets of penalties in Italy — and what foreign companies selling here must do immediately

A landmark ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union, delivered on 30 April 2026 in *Lidl Italia* (Case C‑301/25), has confirmed that a single misleading commercial practice in Italy can simultaneously breach two separate EU regulatory frameworks and attract two distinct sets of fines. Combined with the Italian Competition Authority's (AGCM) €9 million dark-pattern fine against eDreams in January 2026, this creates a compliance risk that most foreign companies selling into Italy have not priced in. This article breaks down what happened, why it matters to non-Italian businesses, and what to do about it.

One label, two fines: the rule no foreign company expected

Your company sells a product into Italy. The packaging has been approved by your in-house counsel. It complies with the relevant EU food information regulation. You have a terms-of-service page on your website that your Irish or Delaware lawyers signed off. You assume that is enough.

It is not — and the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has now said so explicitly.

On 30 April 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union delivered its judgment in Lidl Italia Srl v Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato (Case C‑301/25), confirming that a single instance of misleading food labelling can simultaneously breach two distinct EU regulatory frameworks, and attract penalties under both.

Italy's Competition and Market Authority — the Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato (AGCM) — had fined Lidl Italia €1 million for presenting its pasta products in a way that created a strong impression of Italian-grown wheat, while the product actually contained wheat sourced from a mix of EU and non-EU countries. The fine was issued under Italian consumer protection law implementing the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Directive 2005/29/EC), raising the question of whether the more specific food labelling rules under Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 should have applied exclusively.

Lidl argued that, because Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 already governs food information, the AGCM had no jurisdiction to apply the broader consumer law framework on top of it. The CJEU rejected that argument entirely.

What the CJEU actually decided — and why it is not what the industry hoped

At the heart of the case was Article 3(4) of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Directive 2005/29/EC), which provides that where a conflict exists between the Directive and another EU instrument governing specific aspects of unfair commercial practices, the more specific rule takes precedence. The CJEU definitively established that the consumer-protection frameworks under Directive 2005/29/EC and Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. There is no conflict between them — they are complementary. Where there is no direct conflict, both apply.

Importantly, the Court did not find that Lidl's statements were false. Rather, it held that the packaging, taken as a whole, could lead consumers to the wrong conclusion about the product's origin. That broader impression — the cumulative effect of imagery, design, and presentation — was sufficient to treat the marketing as misleading and justify the fine.

This is the element that most foreign businesses miss. Italian (and CJEU) consumer law does not ask whether any individual claim on a label is technically accurate. It asks whether the overall impression on the consumatore medio — the average consumer — is distorted. A packaging design that creates a false geographic impression, even through colour, font choices, and imagery rather than explicit written claims, falls within the AGCM's enforcement remit.

Under Article 20(2) of the Italian Consumer Code (Codice del Consumo), a commercial practice is unfair and therefore prohibited where it is "contrary to professional diligence and is false or likely to materially distort the economic behaviour of the average consumer it reaches or targets."

Unlike in most common-law jurisdictions: the "technically true" defence does not work in Italy

Foreign companies — particularly those from the UK, United States, Canada, and Australia — tend to approach compliance on the basis that provided no individual statement is false, there is no liability. Italy's AGCM operates on a fundamentally different premise.

Unlike in most common-law countries, where consumer protection agencies typically focus on false statements of fact, the AGCM can and routinely does pursue conduct that is technically accurate in every individual claim but misleading in its overall commercial effect. This applies to packaging, advertising, website user interfaces, and digital subscription flows alike. A disclaimer buried in terms and conditions does not cure misleading presentation further up the page. Sector-specific compliance (food law, financial services regulation, telecoms rules) does not shield a company from a concurrent AGCM investigation under the Italian Consumer Code. The Lidl Italia judgment of the CJEU has now confirmed this at EU level, making the point unchallengeable across all twenty-seven member states.

Dark patterns and digital subscriptions: the €9 million eDreams precedent

The Lidl Italia ruling arrived against a backdrop of aggressive AGCM enforcement that had already set a high-water mark in the digital sector.

In its assembly of 27 January 2026, the AGCM sanctioned the online travel agency eDreams for two distinct misleading and aggressive practices employing dark patterns. eDreams had presented its Prime subscription offer using ambiguous information about the characteristics and benefits of the subscription, exploiting time-pressure and artificial-scarcity techniques to rush consumers' purchase decisions and steer them towards subscribing. This conduct — combining deceptive and aggressive elements — infringed Articles 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, and 26 of the Italian Consumer Code and attracted a fine of €6,000,000.

The Authority additionally found that eDreams had obstructed the exercise of the right to withdraw from the Prime subscription, both before and after the trial period expired, through retention strategies operated via customer service agents. This second practice, classified as aggressive, attracted a further fine of €3,000,000.

The total, therefore, was €9 million for a single investigation. The AGCM did not treat the two practices as one infringement; it stacked the penalties. That is precisely the dual-liability logic that the CJEU has now confirmed applies across regulatory frameworks too.

Beyond monetary penalties, an AGCM decision may impose further obligations: the company may be ordered to eliminate the harmful effects of the unfair practice — for instance by refunding deceived consumers — and to publish the penalty decision on its own website. Failure to comply within the deadline set (generally sixty days) triggers further sanctions.

When the AGCM has jurisdiction — and when sector regulators take over

A critical practical question for foreign companies is which Italian authority has jurisdiction over a given practice. The answer is not always the AGCM.

For conduct to constitute an unfair commercial practice it is not sufficient that it violates specific sector-specific rules, even those enacted to protect consumers; the practice must be apt to mislead the average consumer on important elements of the contract, or to induce the consumer to take a commercial decision they would not otherwise have taken, or to limit the freedom of choice of the average consumer in relation to the product through harassment, coercion, or undue influence.

The Council of State (Consiglio di Stato), Section VI, in its judgment of 3 February 2026, no. 887, clarified the boundary between the AGCM's general consumer-protection jurisdiction and the powers of sector-specific regulators (such as the telecoms authority, AGCOM). Where a sector regulator has comprehensive enforcement powers over a specific practice, the AGCM's role may be displaced. But that displacement is narrow: unless the sector regime expressly and comprehensively covers the specific unfair conduct at issue, the AGCM retains full jurisdiction and can act in parallel. For food, financial products, and online platforms, the post-Lidl Italia position is that overlap is the rule, not the exception.

The AGCM's recent enforcement digest for May–June 2026 shows the Authority actively applying sanctions in the areas of antitrust, as well as consumer protection in unfair commercial practices involving financial and banking services, misleading communications, and deceptive trader conduct. This is not a regulator reducing its caseload.

What foreign companies should do now

The Lidl Italia ruling and the eDreams fine together establish a compliance map that any foreign company selling products or digital services in Italy must follow. The key steps are these.

First, audit your packaging, advertising, and website interfaces for overall impression, not just individual claim accuracy. Engage someone who understands how the average Italian consumer reads your material, not just whether each statement is technically defensible.

Second, if you operate a subscription service or any form of premium digital offer in Italy, review your sign-up and cancellation flows against the AGCM's dark-pattern enforcement record. The Italian Consumer Code articles at issue in eDreams (Articles 20–26 of Legislative Decree no. 206 of 6 September 2005) are the standard framework; there is no exemption for platforms incorporated outside Italy.

Third, if you sell food products or products with geographic indications in Italy, do not assume that compliance with Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 on food information closes the AGCM file. After the CJEU's ruling in Case C‑301/25, the AGCM can simultaneously fine you under the Directive 2005/29/EC framework for the same labelling, up to €10 million.

Fourth, take AGCM commitment proceedings seriously. The AGCM's discretion in accepting or rejecting offers of commitment to cease unfair conduct from companies subject to infringement proceedings is subject to judicial review only on clearly illogical or unreasonable grounds. Negotiating a commitment — an undertaking to change conduct — before a final penalty decision is often the most effective way to reduce both the reputational and financial damage. But the window for doing so closes quickly once a formal investigation opens.

Fifth, note the reputational sting. The AGCM routinely orders companies to publish penalty decisions on their own websites. For a brand with a significant Italian consumer base, that obligation alone can cost more than the fine itself.

The Latin principle in dubio pro reo — in case of doubt, for the accused — does not govern the AGCM's decision to investigate. The regulator can open proceedings on the basis of a complaint, a market scan, or a whistleblower report, and the burden of demonstrating the practice's fairness rests substantially on the trader. As the historian and economist Albert O. Hirschman observed, market participants do not exit or raise their voice unless the cost of loyalty to a dysfunctional system becomes too high — and Italian consumer law has, by design, raised the cost of non-compliance to the point where adjustment is less expensive than the fine.

The Lidl Italia judgment closes a loophole that many multinational companies had quietly relied upon. Sector compliance is a floor, not a ceiling. The AGCM can always reach higher.

Do you need legal assistance or a free estimate?

Author: Avv. Marco Panato


Avv. Marco Panato -

Avv. Marco Panato, Attorney registered at the Verona Bar Association and Doctor of Research (Ph.D.) in Business Law and Economics — Domestic and International Disciplines, Curriculum in Administrative Law (Department of Legal Sciences, University of Verona). Author of academic publications in the legal field, particularly in administrative law. He also delivers lectures and advanced professional training.