The July 2026 CJEU ruling on the "closest connection" test and what it means for every company posting staff to Italy
A Court of Justice of the European Union ruling of 9 July 2026 has sharpened the legal test that decides which country's employment law governs a cross-border posting — and the consequences for companies sending staff to Italy are immediate. Combined with Italy's new pay transparency obligations under Legislative Decree no. 96 of 7 May 2026, the compliance landscape has shifted materially. This article explains the ruling, the Italian framework it intersects with, and what foreign employers need to do now.
The question nobody asks until it is too lateYour company has a project in Milan. You send two engineers from your UK or US office for what you call a "temporary posting." Six months pass, then nine, then twelve. At no point does anyone formally review the legal status of the arrangement. Then a labour inspection begins.
This scenario is not hypothetical. It is precisely the factual pattern the Court of Justice of the European Union examined in its judgment of 9 July 2026, in Case C-768/24 — a ruling that has immediate consequences for any foreign company posting workers to Italy.
In that judgment, the CJEU clarified that, to identify the law applicable to a cross-border employment relationship, the decisive criterion is that of the "closest connection," assessed by reference to the objective features of the working relationship itself. The case arose from a dismissal dispute, but the Court's reasoning on applicable law applies directly to posted workers. The underlying dispute involved a Swiss company that had dismissed a manager in accordance with Swiss law, where the manager in fact resided and habitually worked in France; the employee challenged the dismissal, claiming that more protective French employment law applied.
The implications for Italy are stark. Under Regulation (EC) No. 593/2008 (Rome I), a posting agreement typically preserves the law of the sending country as the governing law of the employment contract. But that protection is not absolute. This does not mean that Italian law is irrelevant: working in Italy entails the application of mandatory provisions of national labour law. The situation changes significantly if the posting ceases to be temporary or becomes a stable presence. In that case, the employment relationship's centre of gravity gradually moves to Italian law.
The July 2026 CJEU ruling gives concrete effect to exactly this shift: once the objective facts show that Italy is the habitual place of work, the worker's home-country contract is no longer the shield the sending employer assumed it was.
The Italian framework: what mandatory rules apply the moment a worker arrivesItaly implemented the core EU posting framework through Legislative Decree no. 136 of 17 July 2016, which transposed Directive 2014/67/EU. A worker posted to Italy is entitled to at least the minimum working and employment conditions enjoyed by workers performing similar jobs in Italy, as laid down by legislative provisions and applicable collective labour agreements.
The key mandatory Italian rules that apply from day one — regardless of the law governing the contract — cover minimum pay rates under the relevant national collective agreement (the
contratto collettivo nazionale di lavoro), working time limits under Legislative Decree no. 66 of 8 April 2003, health and safety obligations, equal treatment, and non-discrimination protections. These are not negotiable via a choice-of-law clause. A company based in Dublin, Stuttgart or New York cannot simply import its home-country terms and assume they satisfy Italian law.
Unlike in most common-law countries — where the parties to an employment contract have wide latitude to choose the governing law and rely on it comprehensively — Italian law imposes a distinct, mandatory protective floor that co-exists with the foreign governing law for the entire duration of a genuine posting. The Rome I Regulation preserves the foreign contract's law, but Article 8(1) of that Regulation ensures that the worker cannot be deprived of protections afforded by the mandatory rules of the country where they habitually work. Once the CJEU's "closest connection" test tips the balance,
those mandatory rules stop being a floor and become the entire roof.
The 2026 pay transparency layer: a new trap for posting employersA further layer of obligation took effect in June 2026. Legislative Decree no. 96 of 7 May 2026 was published in Italy's Official Gazette, transposing Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency to enforce equal pay between men and women. This decree entered into force on 7 June 2026 and applies to workers performing work in Italy — which includes posted workers for the duration of their Italian assignment.
The new rules introduce disclosure obligations in the recruitment phase and for the duration of employment, including an obligation to disclose salary ranges for advertised positions; they prohibit employers from asking candidates about previous or current remuneration and impose the use of gender-neutral job titles and descriptions.
For a posting employer, the practical consequence is this: even if your posted worker is not being recruited in Italy, the assignment triggers documentation and pay-comparison duties. If the posted worker can show that a comparable Italian employee earns more for substantially equal work, the Legislative Decree no. 96/2026 framework gives them a directly enforceable right to the difference. This is a new enforcement mechanism that most foreign HR departments have not yet built into their posting documentation.
The pre-posting notification you cannot skipBefore any posting begins, the sending company must file a prior electronic notification through the Italian Ministry of Labour's portal at
servizi.lavoro.gov.it, using the
UNI_DISTACCO_UE form. The notification must be submitted electronically via the UNI_DISTACCO_UE form by midnight on the day before the posting begins, and may be cancelled by midnight on the day the posting starts.
Prior notification is also required for intra-group postings within the same corporate group, for temporary agency workers supplied to a user company established in Italy, for chain postings, and for periods in which posted workers are replaced.
Foreign companies also need to appoint a liaison representative in Italy, reachable by the Italian Labour Inspectorate (
Ispettorato Nazionale del Lavoro), and must hold available in Italy — in Italian or in English — the employment contract, pay slips, working time records and, where applicable, A1 social security portability certificates.
Posted workers to Italy need enhanced information and formal notification. Miss these requirements, and you are exposed to fines of €250 to €1,500 per employee, per violation. These fines are per worker, per breached obligation: in a team of ten engineers posted for three months, a single documentation gap multiplied across several obligations reaches a level that makes compliance far cheaper than inspection.
The sham-posting risk: where criminal law entersA sham posting can be identified where the sending company is a shell that exercises no genuine economic activity in the country of origin, or where it does not actually provide a service but merely supplies staff without the required authorisation, or where the posted worker at the time of hiring by the foreign company was already residing and working habitually in Italy.
Italian criminal courts have prosecuted sham-posting as fraudulent labour supply (
somministrazione fraudolenta) under Article 38-bis of Legislative Decree no. 81 of 2015, and, in more serious cases, as fraud against the state. The civil consequence is equally severe: a posting reclassified as sham is treated as if no valid posting ever existed, meaning the worker is deemed to have always been employed by the Italian recipient company, with full job-security protections and end-of-service allowance (TFR) accruing from the start.
Ubi emolumentum, ibi onus — where the benefit is, there lies the burden. The company that profits from cheaper foreign labour rates while operating in Italy cannot escape the obligations that attach to Italian employment simply by maintaining a foreign payroll.
As the legal historian Otto Kahn-Freund observed, labour law does not operate in a vacuum: it is always embedded in a specific economic and social context, and the courts of that context will apply it to whoever operates within its borders.
What a foreign employer should do before the next assignmentThe time to review a posting arrangement is before the worker boards a plane. Once an inspection begins, the documentary gaps are very hard to cure retrospectively.The practical checklist runs as follows. First, determine whether the posting is genuinely temporary — a concrete service of limited and predetermined duration — or whether it is an indefinite transfer dressed as a posting to avoid Italian employment law. The CJEU's "closest connection" analysis will be applied to the facts on the ground, not to the label in the assignment letter.Second, ensure the sending entity has a genuine business presence and payroll in the country of origin. An A1 certificate of continuing social security coverage is necessary but not sufficient: Italian inspectors look at the substance of the sending company's operations, not just its paperwork.Third, file the UNI_DISTACCO_UE notification correctly and on time, appoint the Italian liaison representative, and hold the full personnel file in Italy or make it immediately available digitally.Fourth, audit the posted workers' remuneration against the applicable Italian national collective agreement. Under Legislative Decree no. 96/2026, any gender-based pay gap between the posted worker and a comparable Italian employee creates a legal exposure.Fifth, set a formal review date at the six-month mark. If the posting looks likely to exceed twelve months, the sending company must file an extended-duration notification and, from month thirteen, the posted worker becomes entitled to substantially all Italian employment conditions — not merely the mandatory minimum floor.Assignments that started before 7 June 2026 may already have triggered pay transparency documentation obligations that were not in the original posting agreement. A review of live assignments against the new legislative framework is urgent.
Do you need legal assistance or a free estimate?
Author: Avv. Marco Panato
Avv. Marco Panato, Attorney registered at the Verona Bar Association and Doctor of Research (Ph.D.) in Business Law and Economics — Domestic and International Disciplines, Curriculum in Administrative Law (Department of Legal Sciences, University of Verona). Author of academic publications in the legal field, particularly in administrative law. He also delivers lectures and advanced professional training.